Building the Business Case
Solution Matrix Ltd ®

Materiality Concept in Accounting Explained
Definition, Meaning, and Application

Business Encyclopedia ISBN 978-1-929500-10-9. Revised 2014-04-17.

The materiality concept is the universally accepted accounting principle that all material matters are to be disclosed.

Financial statement items are considered material (large enough to matter) if they could influence the economic decisions of users. The materiality concept is the universally accepted accounting principle that all material matters are to be disclosed.

The materiality concept is the principle in accounting that trivial matters are to be disregarded, and all important matters are to be disclosed. Items that are large enough to matter are material items. Materiality refers especially to:

•  The level of detail appropriate for different financial reports.

•  The importance of errors such as:

–  Reporting expenses, revenues, liabilities, equities, or assets in inappropriate accounts, or reporting them for incorrect reporting periods.

–  Omitting or failing to report important financial data.

The materiality concept is an established, recognized accounting convention. Another such convention is the historical cost convention, by which transactions are recorded at the price prevailing when the transaction is made, and assets are valued at original cost. Comparing the two conventions, however, historical costs are usually ascertained and agreed rather objectively, with little uncertainty, whereas applying the materiality concept may call for more subjective judgment. Moreover, the subjective judgments of senior management, accountants, auditors, boards of directors, stockholders, and potential business partners, can differ, especially when competing interests are involved.

Why is the concept important and necessary in financial accounting? Note that some of the reasons explained below also show that materiality is necessary and inevitable in business case analysis, as well. 

What is material? What is not material?

The materiality concept addresses omissions and misstatements in accounting reports and in business case analysis. The central question is: Do they matter?

Some omissions are inevitable and desirable in both cases.

  • An income statement, for instance, is meant to help stockholders, management, and boards of directors make judgments about investing, managing, and evaluating management performance. A statement with too much detail could obscure the "larger picture," could be difficult to prepare, and difficult to read and use. An income statement with too much detail could also risk revealing sensitive information that should remain confidential.
  • Similarly, a business case analysis is a tool for decision support and planning. Non material details are can be simply distracting and pointless.

On the other hand, omission or misstatement of material items would work against the purpose in either case. 

In the United States, the predominant approach to deciding what is material and what is not, is the view written in the GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting principles) that items are material if they could individually or collectively influence the economic decisions of users, taken on the basis of financial statements.

This definition is consistent with a more formal statement from the board responsible for GAAP, the United States Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). Here, materiality refers to ... "the magnitude of an omission or misstatement of accounting information that, in the light of surrounding circumstances, makes it probable that the judgment of a reasonable person relying on the information would have been changed or influenced by the omission or misstatement.1

Judging the judgment:
What constitutes abuse of the materiality concept?

Abuses of the concept are more likely to have serious legal consequences in accounting, than in business case analysis.

For accountants, GAAP and FASB have resisted putting precise quantitative value on the size of misstatement or omission that qualifies as an error in materiality. Nevertheless, in reaching judgment on specific cases, auditors and courts have utilized several "rules of thumb."

  • On an income statement, an omission or error greater than 5% of Profit (before tax), or greater than 0.5% of sales revenues is more likely to be considered "large enough to matter."
  • On a balance sheet, a questionable entry more than 0.3 to 0.5% of total assets or more than 1% of total equity, is more likely to be viewed suspiciously.

The final judgment on a suspected materiality abuse, however, will also consider factors besides the magnitude of the error. Auditors and courts will also consider 

  1. Motivation and intent behind the error 
    If the intent is to keep stock prices artificially high, inflate reported earnings, or inappropriately influence merger / acquisition decisions, for instance, an abuse judgment is more likely.
  2. The likely effect on user perceptions and judgment.
    An accounting statement error with large "Indirect manufacturing labor expenses and overhead expenses" misclassified as "Direct manufacturing labor" might not be seen as materiality abuse, since both kinds of expense contribute to cost of goods sold and the gross profit / gross margin result is the same regardless of which category has the labor in question.

    A statement with the same large expenses misclassified below the gross profit line under Operating Expenses instead of above the gross profit line, would more likely be seen as fraudulent because the misstatement does inappropriately improve gross profits.

—————————
1. Financial Accounting Standards Board, Statement of Financial Accounting
    Concepts No. 2, Qualitative Characteristics of Accounting Information.

By Marty Schmidt. Copyright © 2004-

Power Tools for
Business Professionals

Business Case Essentials

The complete concise guide to what belongs in your case and why. The trusted authority on business case analysis provides clear, practical, step-by-step guidance.

Essentials—The most frequently cited case-building guide in print.

Financial
Metrics Pro

Handbook, textbook, and live templates in one Excel tool. Comprehensive usage and implementation of ROI, IRR, Working capital, EPS, and 150+ more cash flow and financial statement metrics.

Metrics Pro features the Analyst Workbench & Chairman's View.

Business Case
Templates 2014

Integrated Word, Excel, and PowerPoint Template system designed to help you build a professional quality case quickly and easily.

Templates 2014—When you need a real business case.

Project
Progress Pro

Finish time-critical projects on time with the power of statistical process control tracking. The Excel-based system makes implementing project control charting easy to use—even for those without a statistical background.

Progress Pro—When projects simply have to finish on time.

The Premier Professional Training Seminars

Building the Business Case Seminar Participants

Learn how to make your case.

Train and practice with the leading authority on business case analysis. Join more than 16,000 professionals worldwide who have mastered the 6D Framework in Basic and Master Class seminars.

Earn professional education credit while you build your case!

Download case-building books and software when you register! Join the next class in...

   London
   New York City
   Kuala Lumpur